Divine 12 Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting

Oh, darling, is it that time of year already? The air is getting crisp, and I can just smell the cinnamon starting to float around! If you’re like me, you live for those seasonal treats that just taste like comfort and celebration. These vintage recipes are my absolute favorite to pull out, and this version is topping the charts this year. Seriously, the magic behind these Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting is that they are impossibly moist, spiced just right, and crowned with the fluffiest, tangiest frosting you can dream up. It’s the ultimate holiday one-two punch, and trust me, people will beg you for the recipe!

Why You Will Crave These Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting

Now, why should you stop everything and bake these right now? I promise these aren’t just another dry little cake batter dressed up with holiday spices. These are special! They bake up perfectly every time, and the frosting is seriously addictive. I keep wanting to sneak one straight from the cooling rack, oops! If you need convincing, here’s why this batch is going to disappear before you even get them frosted:

• They are unbelievably moist, thanks to that touch of eggnog right in the batter. They stay fresh for days!
• The flavor profile is perfectly balanced: warm nutmeg and vanilla meet that rich, creamy eggnog taste.
• This recipe is surprisingly fast! You can have these in the oven in under 20 minutes, which is a miracle during the busy holiday season.
• That cream cheese frosting isn’t just sitting there; it’s sharp and tangy enough to cut through the sweetness of the cupcake beautifully.
• They look like they took hours of effort, but really, they’re simple enough for a weeknight treat.
• They smell absolutely divine while baking—like Christmas morning exploded in your kitchen!

Ingredients Needed for Perfect Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting

Listen, the secret to baking success is always grabbing the right ingredients and making sure they are ready to go. Don’t just glance at this list; pull everything out now! Having your fats softened correctly makes a world of difference, especially when we start creaming them later for that lift. This recipe shines because it uses simple things, but we have to treat them right. Here are the things you need to assemble before we even think about turning the oven on. If you want to check out my favorite mixing techniques, I wrote a little something on that too over here.

For the Moist Eggnog Cupcakes

Make sure your butter is properly softened—not melted, just soft enough for your finger to make an imprint easily. That’s key for that initial creaming step!

• 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
• 1 1/2 teaspoons baking powder
• 1/2 teaspoon salt
• 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened
• 1 cup granulated sugar
• 2 large eggs (make sure these are room temperature!)
• 1/2 cup eggnog
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg

For the Rich Cream Cheese Frosting

When whipping up the frosting, your cream cheese and butter must both be soft. If they are cold, you end up with tiny, annoying lumps, and nobody wants lumpy frosting, right? Also, make sure you sift that powdered sugar!

• 8 ounces cream cheese, softened
• 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened
• 3 cups powdered sugar, sifted
• 1/4 cup eggnog (use some of what’s leftover from the cake!)
• 1/2 teaspoon rum extract (only use this if you want that extra holiday kick!)

Step-by-Step Instructions to Make Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting

Okay, now that everything is measured out and waiting patiently, let’s get mixing! This flow is designed to keep everything smooth and airy so we avoid that dense, heavy cupcake texture. We move from the dry stuff to the wet stuff, and then—magic! Seriously, it’s so fast once you get into the rhythm. If you want to read up on how to manage a great pound cake texture, which uses similar creaming methods, this guide is fantastic. Just remember: patience in the beginning pays off hugely in the end!

Preparing the Cupcake Batter and Baking

First things first: get that oven warming up to 350°F (175°C). I always get my 12-cup muffin tin lined with papers right away so everything’s ready to go. Start by whisking your flour, baking powder, and salt together in a medium bowl—that’s our dry team. Then, in the big bowl, cream that softened butter and sugar until it looks fluffy and pale. Don’t rush this! Beat in your two eggs one at a time. Once those eggs are happy, fold in half a cup of eggnog, vanilla, and that nutmeg. When you bring the dry ingredients into the wet, add them slowly and mix only until they barely disappear. If you see streaks, that’s okay—we do NOT want to overmix them!

Spoon the batter evenly into those 12 cups, filling them about two-thirds full. Slide them into the oven for about 18 to 20 minutes. You want that toothpick test to come out clean! Let them chill in the pan for five minutes before moving them to a wire rack to cool completely. And I mean *completely*.

Creating the Signature Cream Cheese Frosting

While those lovely little cakes are cooling off—don’t cheat and try to frost them warm, I’ve been there!—we make the topping. Start by beating the softened cream cheese and the half-cup of butter together until it’s totally smooth. You want zero lumps here, so be thorough! Next, start adding in those three cups of sifted powdered sugar slowly while the mixer is running on low. Once it starts coming together, kick up the speed a bit. Finally, mix in the quarter cup of eggnog and that optional rum extract until it’s light, airy, and creamy. If it seems too thick, splash in half a teaspoon more liquid.

Assembling Your Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting

This is the payoff moment! As I mentioned, the biggest hurdle for any cupcake is waiting. If the cakes are even slightly warm, your beautiful Cream Cheese Frosting will melt into a sweet, sad puddle. Once those beauties are fully cooled down, either pipe that rich frosting on with a fancy tip—I like a big star swirl—or just use a small offset spatula and swirl it on generously. For a little extra flair, dust the top with a tiny pinch of ground nutmeg. That’s it! Holiday perfection achieved in under an hour total time.

Tips for Achieving the Best Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting

Honestly, baking is mostly chemistry, but the joy comes from knowing the little tricks that make the chemistry work for *you*. The absolute biggest thing you must nail for these best cream recipes is temperature. Room temperature eggs and butter are non-negotiable for the cake batter—they emulsify so much better, giving you that necessary airy lift!

My huge warning sign, the thing that always ruins a batch fast, is overmixing once the flour goes in. I learned this the hard way when I was rushing one year; I mixed until I didn’t see any white streaks, and I ended up with cupcakes that tasted sort of… chewy? Don’t do it! Mix just until you see the last bit of dry flour disappear, and then stop immediately before you ruin that lovely structure we worked so hard to build.

If your kitchen is unusually warm, your cream cheese frosting can get sloppy fast. If you finish mixing and it looks a bit too soft, just pop the whole bowl into the fridge for fifteen minutes for a quick chill before piping. That saves the day almost every time!

Ingredient Notes and Substitutions for Eggnog Cupcakes

We talked about getting the ingredients right, but let’s iron out the sticky points, like what to do if you can’t find exactly what’s on the list. Baking is supposed to be fun, not stressful because one ingredient is missing! If you look at my list for the Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting, you might see a couple of things that require a little planning, especially that rum extract. If you aren’t a fan of extracts or just happen to have a bottle of something better lying around, I have a few pointers for you.

First off, let’s talk eggnog. Since this flavor is the star, you want the best you can find! If you’re using store-bought, grab one that you actually enjoy drinking on its own. If it tastes sugary and flat by itself, it’ll taste that way in your cupcakes too. I often look for eggnogs fortified with real nutmeg or a touch of vanilla. Now, if you happen to have some leftover from a party, that’s perfect, but remember to use the colder, thicker stuff on the richer side for the frosting, as that helps keep it firm.

About that optional rum extract in the frosting—it gives such a lovely, warm aftertaste! If you look at my notes near my other sauce guides, you know I love a good swap. If you’d rather have a stronger, deeper flavor than the extract provides, you absolutely can substitute it with real dark rum. Just use about half the amount of extract called for—say, 1/4 teaspoon of rum—because liquid alcohol is much stronger than extract flavor concentration, and we don’t want soup for frosting!

Also, be mindful of your spices. If your ground nutmeg has been sitting in the cupboard since last Christmas, toss it! Flat spices ruin a spiced cupcake faster than anything. Freshly ground is always best, even if you use a coffee grinder dedicated just to spices. It makes the whole cupcake taste brighter and more festive, truly taking your Cream Cheese Frosting to the next level.

Storage and Make-Ahead for Your Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting

These are the perfect make-ahead treat, which is fantastic because during the holidays, who needs dishes waiting for you? But here’s the thing: because that lovely, tangy cream cheese frosting is involved, they have different storage needs than, say, a plain sugar cookie. You absolutely cannot leave these on the counter overnight once they are frosted!

For unfrosted cupcakes, you’re in luck! Bake them up to two days ahead. Just let them cool completely—and I mean glass-clear cool—and store them in a single layer in an airtight container on the counter. They stay beautifully moist. If you try to stack them, you’ll just smash your perfect little dome tops, and we can’t have that, can we?

Once they are loaded up with that gorgeous topping, they must go into the chiller. Pop them into a clean, airtight container. I usually use one of those clear plastic containers with a lid, but make sure there’s a little bit of space between the top of the frosting swirl and the lid so it doesn’t get smushed. Honestly, they are best within two days, but they will keep for up to four days in the fridge.

Now, can you freeze them? Yes, you can freeze the *unfrosted* cakes for up to three months! Wrap them tightly in plastic wrap first, then slip them into a freezer bag. When you need them, just thaw them on the counter while you whip up a fresh batch of that amazing frosting. If you absolutely must freeze them frosted—and I only do this if I’m desperate—make sure you place them in the container completely open like this, then cover them loosely with plastic wrap, and finally seal the lid. Thaw them in the fridge overnight. They might weep a tiny bit, so check them before serving, but it’s usually fine!

Serving Suggestions for Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting

These little gems are showstoppers all on their own, but presentation always makes the experience sweeter, doesn’t it? When I bring these Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting out, I like to make the whole spread feel festive, so I pair them with drinks that match that cozy, spiced vibe. Forget plain water; we are going all-in on the holiday cheer!

For a cozy afternoon gathering—you know, when everyone is nursing a holiday sweater and the lights are low—you cannot beat pairing these with a steaming cup of strong coffee or espresso. The slight bitterness of good coffee is the perfect foil for how rich that cream cheese frosting is. If you have kids around, or if you just want something non-caffeinated, grab some spiced apple cider. Heating the cider up slightly makes the whole room smell incredible, working in tandem with the nutmeg from the cupcakes.

Garnishes to Make Them Sparkle

Even if you pipe that frosting high and gorgeous, a little something extra on top seals the deal! The simplest and most effective garnish, in my opinion, is a tiny dusting of freshly grated nutmeg right over the frosting swirl. It really drives home that classic eggnog flavor the minute someone looks at it.

If I’m feeling extra fancy, and sometimes I just need to feel fancy, I’ll crush up some candied ginger! Chop it really fine and sprinkle it over the top just before serving. The tiny bits of crystalized sugar catch the light beautifully, and the slight heat of the ginger is just divine with the creamy vanilla base. It’s a little crunch, a little spice, and a whole lot of gorgeousness. You could even look at ideas for floats or fun drinks, like checking out how they garnish something simple like a Shirley Temple float; you can borrow styling tips even if the drink is different!

These cupcakes are just perfect for cookie platters because they feel substantial, but they’re easy to grab when people are mingling. They disappear fast, so always make an extra batch!

Frequently Asked Questions About Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting

I know when I look at a recipe, a million little questions pop into my head right away. Do I have to use that specific extract? Can I skip chilling? Will these even make it to tomorrow? Don’t worry, I’ve run into all these snags myself over the years, especially when making elaborate holiday bakes like these lovely Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting. I’ve gathered the most common questions people ask me about this recipe right here to save you some guesswork!

Can I use store-bought eggnog in the Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting?

\

Yes, absolutely! You don’t have to go stressfully searching for artisanal, locally made eggnog if you can’t find it or if your grocery store is picked over. Store-bought works perfectly fine for both the cake batter and the frosting in this recipe. My only piece of advice is just to check the consistency. If you are using store-bought, try to buy one that isn’t super watery. The thicker the eggnog is, the less additional liquid you’ll have to add to the frosting, which keeps it stable and fluffy. If it seems a little thin, just hold back on adding all the *quarter cup* to the frosting until the very end—you might find you only need three-quarters of it!

How to prevent the Cream Cheese Frosting from becoming too soft?

\

This is essential, especially if you live in a warmer climate, or if you’re having a big party and your kitchen tends to get warm from all those lovely people gathered around! The main culprits for soft frosting are warm cream cheese/butter, or simply over-beating it once the sugar is incorporated. If you notice your frosting smoothing out too much and looking shiny right after you finish beating it, stop immediately. Take the bowl and pop it into the refrigerator for about 10 to 15 minutes. It doesn’t need to get rock hard—just cool enough so it holds its shape again. That quick chill works wonders, and then you can pipe those perfect swirls high onto your cute little desserts.

Another technique I always use is to make sure my mixing bowl and beater attachments are cool when I start the frosting. You can stick them in the freezer for ten minutes before you begin! That little bit of cold prep makes it so much easier to keep that topping stiff and glorious enough to handle the rum extract without turning runny.

Estimated Nutritional Snapshot

Now, listen up, because this is the part where we talk about the numbers, but please keep in mind this is just a best guess! Nobody’s counting too closely when a holiday treat like perfect Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting is involved. I ran these numbers through my usual online calculator, but since homemade ingredients can vary so much—like how much butter sneaks into the bowl or how big those ‘large eggs’ really are—treat this as a general guideline, not gospel. If you are curious about how sugars compare across different foods, take a peek at this great article on fruit sugars!

This snapshot is based on one glorious cupcake serving:

• Calories: Around 350 – Worth every single bite, I promise you!
• Total Fat: About 18 grams. Remember, we used real butter, and that’s what gives us amazing flavor and moisture!
• Carbohydrates: Roughly 45 grams. This includes all that wonderful sugar that makes the batter and frosting so decadent.
• Protein: Around 4 grams. That little boost comes mostly from the eggs and the dairy in the eggnog and cream cheese.

The biggest takeaway here is that these are a treat, meant for enjoying during the holidays! They pack a punch of richness, which is exactly what you want in a decadent dessert like this. If you’re worried about the sugar, remember that a lot of that comes from the amazing cream cheese swirl on top!

Share Your Holiday Baking Success

You know, the kitchen feels empty if I bake something wonderful and don’t get to share the results! I pour so much love into perfecting these Eggnog Cupcakes Cream Cheese Frosting recipes, and seeing them come to life in your homes is truly what makes all the testing worthwhile. Your pictures are the best motivation for me to keep experimenting and writing down all these family secrets!

So, after you’ve let your Cream Cheese Frosting set up perfectly and you’ve served these beauties to your guests, I really want to hear all about it! Did the rum extract give you that perfect little kick you were hoping for? Did the kids devour them before you got a chance to try one? Don’t be shy!

Please, please, please leave a star rating right underneath this section. Your feedback tells me exactly what I need to tweak or what I nailed perfectly for next time. If you made any little adjustments—maybe you swapped in some bourbon in the frosting instead of rum, or perhaps you added some crushed pecans around the edge—let me know! Sharing those little hacks with the community makes these recipes stronger for everyone.

And if you snapped a picture of your finished platter, tag me on social media! I love seeing your successful bakes, especially when they look festive enough to be on the cover of a magazine. If you’re already looking for your next bake sale conqueror or holiday treat, check out some ideas for other fantastic holiday cookies on the site!

Happy baking, my friends. I can’t wait to see what you all create!

Print